top of page

Various methods for tracking body composition: Pros and Cons

Doctor with his patient discussing her health

In the world of health and fitness, weight has long been the dominant metric used to assess progress. But weight alone tells only a fraction of the story. Two people can weigh the same yet have vastly different health profiles depending on their body composition. So, what exactly is body composition, and why does it matter?


What is Body Composition?


Body composition refers to the proportions of different components that make up your body, primarily muscle, fat, bone, and water. Unlike a simple number on a scale, body composition provides insight into your overall health, fitness level, and risk for chronic diseases. Higher muscle mass, for instance, is associated with better metabolic health, while excess body fat—especially visceral fat—can contribute to cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and other conditions.


Understanding your body composition allows you to set more effective health goals, whether that’s increasing lean mass, reducing fat percentage, or improving overall fitness. But tracking these changes accurately requires more than just stepping on a scale. Several methods are available to measure body composition, each with its own strengths and limitations.


Methods of Measuring Body Composition


1. Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA)


Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) is a common method found in many smart scales and handheld devices. It works by sending a weak electrical current through the body and measuring the resistance encountered. Since muscle contains more water than fat, it conducts electricity better, allowing BIA devices to estimate body fat percentage, lean body mass, and sometimes even water retention.


Pros:

  • Convenient and easy to use at home

  • Quick results

  • Found in many affordable consumer devices


Cons:

  • Accuracy can be affected by hydration levels, food intake, and time of day

  • Less precise than more advanced methods

  • Can be inconsistent across different brands and models


2. Dual-Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DEXA Scan)


DEXA scans use low-dose X-rays to differentiate between bone, fat, and lean tissue, making them one of the most accurate methods available. Originally designed to measure bone density, DEXA is now widely used to assess body composition in clinical and research settings.


Pros:

  • Highly accurate

  • Measures bone mineral content, fat mass, and lean mass separately

  • Provides regional fat distribution data


Cons:

  • Requires a clinical setting and specialized equipment

  • Expensive and not widely accessible for regular tracking

  • Involves a small amount of radiation


3. Hydrostatic Weighing


Also known as underwater weighing, this method determines body composition based on water displacement. Since fat is less dense than water and muscle is more dense, the technique measures body volume and density to estimate body fat percentage.


Pros:

  • Very accurate when performed correctly

  • Longstanding method trusted by researchers


Cons:

  • Requires access to specialized facilities

  • Can be uncomfortable for some individuals

  • Not practical for frequent measurements


4. Air Displacement Plethysmography (Bod Pod)


This method works similarly to hydrostatic weighing but uses air displacement instead of water. The subject sits inside an enclosed chamber, and body volume is determined based on air pressure changes.


Pros:

  • Accurate and non-invasive

  • Doesn’t require immersion in water

  • Quick test duration


Cons:

  • Expensive and requires specialized equipment

  • Limited availability outside of research and clinical settings

  • Results can be affected by clothing and body temperature


5. 3D Body Scanning Technology


One of the most innovative and accessible ways to track body composition is through 3D body scanning. Companies like Size Stream offer advanced scanning solutions that use AI and machine learning to analyze body metrics from millions of data points. Unlike traditional methods that focus solely on weight or body fat percentage, 3D scanners provide a full-body visual representation along with precise measurements of different body parts.

One example of this technology available for home use is the MeThreeSixty app, which offers a free standard subscription that includes body fat percentage, lean body mass, and 12 additional measurements. Size Stream’s technology leverages data from over 2 million body scans to provide additional insights, including BMI, Bone Mineral Content, Fat Mass Index, Resting Metabolic Rate, and Visceral Adipose Tissue.


Pros:

  • Highly visual, allowing users to track changes over time

  • More precise than traditional body fat scales

  • Convenient for at-home use

  • AI-driven insights provide deeper health metrics

  • Encourages motivation by visually demonstrating progress


Cons:

  • Accuracy depends on camera quality and positioning

  • Requires a mobile device or scanner access

  • May not be as precise as DEXA scans in clinical settings


Why 3D Body Scanners Are the Future of At-Home Tracking


For individuals serious about tracking their body composition without the hassle of visiting a lab or clinic, 3D body scanning is a game-changer. The ability to visualize changes in body shape, rather than relying solely on numbers, provides a powerful motivational tool. Unlike weight alone, which fluctuates due to factors like water retention, 3D scans offer a more holistic view of progress over time.


Additionally, AI and machine learning advancements have significantly improved the accuracy of these tools. Size Stream’s technology, backed by a massive dataset, ensures a level of precision that was once only possible in research-grade methods. Whether you’re an athlete fine-tuning performance, someone looking to lose fat while preserving muscle, or simply interested in a more comprehensive health assessment, 3D body scanning provides a practical and engaging way to stay on track.


Choosing the Right Method for You


The best method for tracking body composition depends on your needs, access, and frequency of measurement. If you’re looking for a quick, at-home solution, BIA scales or 3D body scanning apps like MeThreeSixty offer convenience and accessibility. If precision is your priority and you’re willing to invest in periodic assessments, a DEXA scan or Bod Pod might be worth considering.


Ultimately, the most important factor is consistency. No matter which method you choose, regular tracking will provide the most valuable insights into your progress. Body composition changes happen over weeks and months, not days, so focusing on long-term trends rather than daily fluctuations will yield the best results.


The Takeaway


Body composition is a far more insightful measure of health than weight alone. With advancements in technology, tracking it has become easier and more accessible than ever. Whether through traditional methods like DEXA scans and hydrostatic weighing or cutting-edge AI-driven 3D body scanning, understanding your body’s unique composition empowers you to make smarter health decisions. For those looking for a balance of accuracy, convenience, and motivation, 3D body scanning stands out as the future of at-home body composition tracking.


Embrace the technology, track your progress intelligently, and take control of your health with tools designed for real insights and real results.


Interested in incorporating MeThreeSixty into your personal health management plan? Download it today and start scanning. If you want to discuss incorporating digital measuring into your business? Connect with our business development team today.

bottom of page